Dark Data and Measuring Invisible Impact in Your Facebook Community

In digital communities, good brand managers spend their time observing and interacting with the hundreds or maybe even thousands of fans who engage daily by commenting and posting. These vocal fans are incredibly important, but they represent only a part of the story. Over 80 percent of brand fans are lurkers – quiet fans that neither comment nor post.

As the largest social community, creating Facebook posts that appeal to your silent majority is as important as engaging your loyal brand advocates. The silent majority refers to fans that are being reached by your brand, but don’t take the actions to Like, comment, reply or share that we typically see from top advocates. They’re statistically some of your most informed and loyal customers, potential future Superfans, and the primary providers of the social currency needed to foster your active advocates: validation.

To appeal to these fans, brands need to gain insight into what they aren’t doing. Marketers need to start focusing on three key metrics to read the dark data that often slips through the cracks for this fan segment: clicks, churn and engagement over time.

Measuring silent fans: Clicks, churn, and engagement over time.

If you can’t measure it, you can’t manage it. Even though this is dark data, measurement is still possible. Some of this information is available immediately within the data Facebook already provides, and some, like fan history and tracking engagements over time, is more readily available through 3^rdparty technology providers. There are a number of supporting metrics like your subscription rate; ratio of fan replies and Likes to fan comments; and interaction on fan shares that you can layer in to give you a more nuanced perspective, but the basic lurker landscape can be derived by looking at clicks, churn, and engagement over time. 

Clicks are a key metric provided by Facebook on a post by post basis, as well as a weekly aggregate. They refer to fans who have clicked into a News Feed post but then didn’t otherwise engaged with that post. With Facebook’s new definition of their Engagement metric that now tracks clicks, this metric can be used as a powerful proxy to determine lurkers’ dark activity.

The most effective way to monitors clicks is looking at clicks/engagements and clicks/reach. Engagement is a catch all that includes shares, Likes, comments, and clicks. Watching how clicks as a ratio of engagements and of reach perform across different post types will give you a good indication of what best hooks your lurkers, and may vary greatly from what hooks your active advocates. Be aware though, that the occasional uncropped recipe photo or hotel pool shot might still appeal to lurkers in the feed without requiring a click through.

To combat lost clicks, one way to start measuring dark data from lurkers would be to work teaser photos into your post mix. Teaser photos are visually grabbing, intentionally cropped photos that hint at a punch line or fuller story that can be reached by clicking through to an externally hosted image or page. Compelling clicks in this manner provides a positive fan experience while presenting a very low obstacle to engagement.

Churn rate, or the rate of fans leaving your page, is a key measurement to determine what silent fans like and don’t like about your brand. Measuring your churn rate regularly and tying it to specific posts or campaigns can act as quantitative analysis that will, over time, allow you to create content that appeals to your fan base as a whole. Since dark data pertains to the majority of your fan base, overall churn rate provided by Facebook serves as a useful reflection of what resonates with your silent majority.

Timing of engagement is a crucial piece of dark data when measuring individuals in your Facebook community. For active fans, use a technology provider or manual research to see how much time elapsed between when they initially Liked your page and when they first engaged. A long average time suggests you’re bringing lurkers along for an enjoyable ride until they’re ready to post, but if the vast majority of your fans engage immediately or not at all, you’re likely not appealing to your passive fans.

Measuring timing between engagements and week over week retention from active fans can also provide valuable dark data on what resonates with these fans; if they start to post more frequently or go through inactive periods, mapping that data to the types of content posted can inform brands about how to stimulate the best discussion with varying segments of their fan base.

Using Dark Data for Good

Once you’ve identified your silent fans, keep track of new engagements as a percentage of overall engagement. Pay attention to the content and initiatives that reliably bring back hardcore fans week over week, and see if it differs from the efforts that get newbies to engage or lurkers to look. This unique perspective can be informative beyond Facebook to influence underlying values of your brand marketing.

Think of dark data as a type of sonar - you’re constantly sending out signals, and now learning to pay attention to what comes back as a method of measuring the shape of your community. As such, benchmarking and reliable measurement over time is essential.

(via)

Related articles

• 5 Things to Think About When Creating a Social Media Content Strategy
• Social Media Branding: 16 Tips to Create a Consistent, Relevant and Trusted Social Brand
• 3 Ways to Identify Brand Advocates
• Nielsen: TV and Online Advertising Will Merge by 2020
• How to Analyze Your Facebook Metrics to Improve Your Marketing

7 Ways You Can Effectively Lose Social Media Followers

Establishing a social media presence is important for almost any brand nowadays. A recent infographic by MBA Online encourages CEOs to use social media because of some compelling statistics. For instance, data shows that 8 in 10 social media users in the U.S. would rather connect with companies on social media sites rather than on their company websites. The infographic also shows that social media campaigns are more effective in generating quality leads.

Knowing how important social media is would naturally motivate you to keep your audience engaged. However, there are some mistakes you can commit that can make you lose followers on social media. If you want to keep your social media followers, steer clear of these practices:

1. Using too many social networks. Unless you have the money to have a fully functioning staff to keep all your social networks updated, then don’t sign up for all the existing social networks out there. Remember that creating meaningful and engaging content takes time and people. Spreading yourself too thin may lead to mediocre posts that would make you irrelevant to subscribers.
2. Focusing on the number of subscribers. Some brands go as far as paying people to subscribe to them. However, the number of followers you have doesn’t determine the quality of their engagement. Building an audience is important. But if the existing audience only serves to exist and not actively engage, it’s going to be hard to keep your future subscribers engaged as well. Remember that social media users thrive on meaningful online relationships. Make this the focus of your social media efforts.
3. Posting all at once. Avoid spamming your followers’ feeds by churning out post after post with little interval in between. Instead, spread out your posts at strategic times of the day. You can also use time-saving tools like Hootsuite or Buffer to help you pre-program your future posts and schedule them more effectively each day.
4. Failing to respond to comments. This isn’t hard to do on some platforms like Facebook where most comments can be visibly seen on the post itself. However, mentions of your brand can be harder to track on forums you’re not a part of or on social networks like Twitter where you get a steady stream of content on your feed. To help you monitor mentions of your brand, you can use a tool like Mentions to track your name and get real-time alerts anywhere on the web, including social networks, blogs, news sites, and forums.
5. Posting irrelevant content. Sharing interesting or entertaining posts is a great way to engage your audience. However, if all you do is share content that’s not relevant to your brand, then what’s the point of people following you? Instead, aim to be helpful to your target audience and use your own unique voice.
6. Being a social media jerk. Remember that you have a brand to protect. Even if you come across trolls and negative commenters on social media, it still pays to be the better person and respond tactfully to all comments, positive or otherwise.
7. Making social media all about you. Yes, it’s your page, but remember that whatever you share also goes to your audience’s stream.

via